At the end of the 1900 century, it was grown four times more rye than wheat here in Sweden.
Rye is a more durable grain, which was crucial at the time. If the harvest was poor, it could mean starvation and, by extension, death.
You simply did not take any unnecessary risks.
But during the 2000 century, wheat became more popular, and Rye was considered the poor man’s diet.
Today Rye begins to regain its popularity, partly because more and more discover the health benefits, but also because people have started to realize that bread baked on rye has a unique and very good taste.
A whole rye bread baked with a high quantity of rye flour will never get the same open airy crumb that you would have got with wheat. Rye flour contains far less gluten, and the quality is quite poor compared to wheat flour.
This recipe contains 100% whole rye. That means the bread will be dense and compact and loaded with flavor.
I would not recommend serving this bread as a side dish to any food, because it simply tastes too much.
But for an open sandwich with cold smoked salmon, dill, and horseradish it’s unbeatable.
That is the way many Swedes eat whole rye bread today. A smørrebrød as The Danish calls it, or smörgås as we say in Sweden.
Personally, I think it’s perfect for breakfast. A thin slice with some butter and your favorite cheese is a great start to the day.
Another good thing with this whole rye bread is that it stays fresh much longer than bread baked on wheat. Rye flour has a better ability to absorb and bind water, something that you probably have noticed if you baked with rye.
Wrap it up in a kitchen towel, and keep it in a plastic bag, and it will stay fresh for a couple of days, perhaps up to a week if you keep it in the refrigerator.
Besides, it’s easy to bake this whole rye bread. You don’t have to bother about forming or scoring the loaf. And there is no need for any kneading or stretch and folds. After the bulk fermentation, you just have to distribute the dough in two bread forms and let them rise before you shuffle them into the oven.
ABOUT THE FLOUR AND STARTER
I have used a whole rye flour that is stone ground for this recipe. Using whole rye provides maximum flavor, and that’s what I want.
The protein content is 9%.
I used my rye starter that has a hydration of 100%
ABOUT THE SEEDS
I have used sunflower seeds, linseeds, flaxseeds, and pumpkin seeds.
Pumpkin seed is not a traditional ingredient in Swedish rye bread, but I think it goes just perfectly with this bread.
ABOUT THE SWEETENER
A dark bread syrup is used as a sweetener for this kind of bread. If you can’t find bread syrup, you can use dark cane syrup instead. If you don’t want any sugar at all, you can add 100 grams of dark beer like Guinness or any kind of porter. Just remember to reduce the amount of water with the same amount.
DAY 1
SOAKING THE SEEDS
Soak the seeds in hot water the night before it’s time to bake. It will make the seed softer and help them release some of their flavors to the crumb.
Place the seeds in a pan or other heatproof container and pour over boiling water. The water shall cover all the seeds. Cover with a lid and let the mixture sit overnight.
LEVAIN
I prepared a levain by mixing 200 grams of water, with 250 grams rye flour and 80 grams mature sourdough starter. I let it ferment overnight, approximately 8 hours in room temperature, about 71ºF/21ºC.
DAY2
MIXING THE DOUGH
Drain the seeds through a strainer and mix with the levain and the rest of the ingredients.
Mix thoroughly so that the seeds are distributed throughout the dough, and so that there is no dry flour left.
BULK FERMENTATION
I let the dough bulk ferment for 4 hours at a temperature of 71°F/21°C. If you want a more sour taste, you can let it ferment longer in a colder environment, but be careful. The taste can become a bit overwhelming.
SHAPING
Here is some good news for those who struggle with your shaping technique.
There is no shaping required for this bread.
You just have to distribute the dough into two bread forms that you have oiled and sprinkled with a thin layer of flour. Use a fine strainer or a sieve.
Smooth the surface with a spatula.
FINAL RISE
The time required for the final rise depends a lot on the ambient temperature. The bread on the pictures proofed for 2. 5 hours at a temperature of 73F/22C.
It should rise about 25-30% of its initial volume.
BAKING
Preheat your oven to 480ºF / 250ºC. You don’t have to bother about steam when baking this bread. But it requires some time in the oven, at least 90 minutes. Bake at the high temperature for 20 minutes, then turn it down to 390ºF / 200ºC.
It’s a good idea to place an extra oven plate over the bread. That will prevent it from being burned on the top.
You can check if it’s ready with a thermometer. The internal temperature should be about 215ºF / 100ºC.
Turn the oven temperature down to 215ºF / 100ºC, but don’t turn it off.
Let the bread cool in the form until you can handle it. Take the bread out of the form and place it in the oven again for about 5 to 10 minutes. That will create a crust on the sides and the bottom of the bread that will prevent it from molding.
Now, unfortunately, you can’t eat this bread the same that you have baked it. It has to rest for at least 24 hours.
This bread is perhaps not for everybody. It has a very strong taste of rye that can be a bit overwhelming.
I remember that I used to hate this kind of bread when I was a kid.
My parents wanted me to eat this bread because it was so healthy.
I was not surprised, because most things that are healthy have a tendency to taste like shit when you are a kid.
But when I grew older, I learned to love this bread, and today I can’t be without it.
I still love airy bread with big holes in the crumb, but for breakfast, this whole rye bread is number one. Give it a try. Perhaps it will be the same for you.
Traditional Swedish whole rye bread
Ingredients
Soaker
- 150 gram sunflower seeds
- 25 gram flax seeds
- 25 gram sesame seeds
- 40 gram pumpkin seeds
Levain
- 250 gram whole rye flour
- 200 gram water
- 80 gram sourdough starter 100% hydration
Sourdough rye bread
- 530 gram levain
- 400 gram water
- 440 gram rye flour
- 50 gram bread syrup
- 18-24* gram salt Look in recipe notes for required amount of salt.*
Instructions
Day 1
- Soak the seeds in hot water the night before it's time to bake. Place the seeds in a pan or other heatproof container and pour over boiling water. The water shall cover all the seeds. Cover with a lid and let the mixture sit overnight.
- Prepare a levain by mixing 200 grams of water, with 250 grams rye flour and 80 grams mature sourdough starter. Let it ferment overnight, approximately 8 hours in room temperature, about 71ºF/21ºC.
Day 2
- Drain the seeds through a strainer and mix with the levain and the rest of the ingredients. Mix thoroughly so that the seeds are distributed throughout the dough, and so that there is no dry flour left.
- Let the dough bulk ferment for 4 hours at a temperature of 71ºF/21ºC. If you want a more sour taste you can let it ferment longer in a colder environment, but be careful. The taste can become a bit overwhelming.
- Distribute the dough into two bread forms that you have oiled and sprinkled with a thin layer of flour. Use a fine strainer or a sieve. Smooth the surface with a spatula.
- Let the dough proof for 2. 5 hours at a temperature of 73ºF/22ºC. It should rise about 25-30% of its initial volume.
- Preheat your oven to 480ºF / 250ºC. You don't have to bother about steam when baking this bread. But it requires some time in the oven, at least 90 minutes. Bake on the high temperature for 20 minutes, then turn it down to 390ºF / 200ºC. It's a good idea to place an extra oven plate over the bread. That will prevent it from being burned on the top. Check if it's ready with a thermometer. The internal temperature should be about 215ºF / 100ºC. Turn the oven temperature down to 215ºF / 100ºC, but don't turn it off.
- Let the bread cool in the form until you can handle it. Take the bread out of the form and place it in the oven again for about 5 to 10 minutes. That will create a crust on the sides and the bottom of the bread that will prevent it from molding.
53 Comments
This looks wonderful. Would adding perhaps 25 grams of fennel seed to the seed mixture hurt? I just love that taste with rye… And not to worry about the bread tasting “too strong.” It’s going to be the base for Lederkrantz cheese (and some Bierkase if I can find it) served with raw red onions , so it can have some “oomph” to it…
No, It won’t hurt. Actually, fennel is quite common in many types of Swedish “traditional” bread. I’m also a big fan of fennel, so I think I’m gonna try it myself. Thanks for the tip.
Do you have an online source for Swedish rye flour? Thanks!
I’m afraid not, What kind of information are you looking for?
Hi..lovely recipe.. I just can’t face making a sourdough starter.. need to be calm and it takes time.. is there any way to skip the lavain
.. is so can you help.. thanks
Hi Mairi.
You can try to use a poolish with instant yeast instead. It’s easier and faster than making a sourdough starter. Replace the levain with the same amount of poolish instead.
Made it according to the directions. Crust was excellent, permanent gooey center. Birds loved it. Will give it another shot.
Perhaps it needed more time in the oven. Did you measure the inner temperature?
Second attempt was successful. Good stuff. What’s happening during the 24 hour rest period after baking? Should it be bagged, wrapped, left on the rack bare?
That’s great, Randy. I use to let the bread cool completely, and then place it in a plastic bag.
Just found your blog today looking for uses for discarded sourdough starter. So many wonderful recipes!! Can you tell me the dimensions of your bread pans? I’d love to make this bread.
Thanks!
Hi Susan. I’m glad you like my recipes. The pan I use is 23x8x6.5 cm (LxWxH). That should be about 9x3x2,5 inches. It is, however, a bit wider at the top.
I’m very happy to find this recipe! My grandfather in Stavanger, Norway, at the age of 94, would walk to the Danish bakery to get something like this bread. I haven’t found anything as good here in the US. In the print version of the recipe, the second rising of the dough in the bread pans is not mentioned. Also, how long about should the bread continue to bake at the lower temperature of 200C?
Hi Lydia,
I understand your grandfather. When you have learned to like this bread it starts to become addictive. It’s hard to find a good 100% rye bread outside Germany or Scandinavia, so it’s better if you bake it yourself. The total baking time is about 90 minutes. It’s a long time, but don’t try to make it shorter. If the inner part of the bread is not fully baked it will be a mess.
It shall increase about 30% in volume during final rise. The time required depends a lot of ambient temperature and helath of starter, but you can expect at least 2-3 hours.
Hey,
Your bread looks awesome on the pictures and I’ve tried baking it twice this past week, but it seems to have come out burnt both times with a really rough taste on the edges. I bake it on a “varmluft” fan 250° 20 minutes + 200° 70 minutes. Have you cooked it on direct heat or how should I adjust to get the nice, softer crust?
Hi Mahir,
First of all, turn of the fan. The convection oven, or varmluftsugn as we say in Sweden, is a great invention.
But not when you are baking bread. It dries out the surface too quickly, making it burn more easily.
You can also try to cover the bread with an extra oven plate during the second half of the baking time.
Hi! Thank you for the recipe it looks great!
I baked it yesterday and the top separated badly from the rest – do you know if it’s a sign of over proofing?
If possible can you please specify your baking times – I baked it at 250 for 20 mins and it got pretty dark ( no fan) then with a sheet on top on 200 for 70 mins. Where does 100C come into the picture and in which temp do I bake it out of the form as the last step? It still turned out yummy and wet unfortunately but there was no way I could bake it for longer the top was already pretty dark.
Is it possible to substitute bread sirap with molasses?I think you mean more sirap and I think it’s a Swedish thing so we cant get it where we live(
Hi Anna,
I think your problem with the top separating is due to too high hydration. Try to reduce the amount of water a bit and see what happens.
When the bread is ready (after about 90 minutes) you take it out from the oven and let it cool until you can handle it.
Then you take it out from the form and put it back into the oven, now at a temperature at 100°C, for 5 to 10 minutes. That will form a crust on the top and sides.
I think you can use molasses, or maybe dark cane syrup.
Hi, could you point me towards the sourdough starter recipe. Thank you
Hi Anna,
I don’t have a recipe for a sourdough starter in my blog. I do however have an ebook describing the whole process about making a sourdough starter. You can get it for free by signing up for my Newsletter. If you are not comfortable about that you can find lots of recipes if you google “how to make your own sourdough starter”. King Arthur flour, for example, has a good recipe.
The taste was great – very authentic. I’m from Germany and we love our dense, seedy breads! However, my loaf didn’t rise much and though I baked it for 90 minutes it was still a little wet in the middle. The crust was great but I don’t know how I get it to rise more. If anything it looked like it had caved in. My sourdough starter is still very young (2.5 weeks).
Hi Eva,
I’m glad you liked it. Next time, try to add slightly less water. Perhaps 390 or 380 gram instead of 400. You can also let it stay longer in the oven. Make sure your starter is strong. It should at least double in volume after feeding. Preferably more. Your starter is a bit young and perhaps it has not reached full strength yet.
When I was little my mum always used to make rye bread. I’ve never been brave enough to attempt it until I found your recipe. The bread came out really well and reminded me of my childhood growing up in Gothenburg. My English children said it tasted 100% better than the store bought one. I will make this again soon.
Tack
Hi Rebecca.
I’m glad you and your family liked it. I guess it’s a challenge to find this kind of bread outside Scandinavia. But even here in Sweden, it’s hard to find this kind of bread nowadays.
Third attempt is finally all I had been hoping for – perfect rise and taste! So good – eating a slice right now with fig mustard and goats cheese! Delicious! Thanks so much for the recipe – I’m glad I gave it another try.
Hi Eva,
Working with rye is a bit special. I’m also glad you gave it another try.
Hi Tomas
Im excited to try your recipe out. I lived in Gothenburg as a child with my English parents and picked up a love for this bread then. Up till now it has been a holiday treat. But having just got into and mastered baking sourdough loaves Im now branching out!
Seeds are a soaking and Im just making the leaven – is this meant to be a ragged dough (on the dry side) or should I adda little more water? Secondly do you think malt extract will work ok for the sweetener?
Hi Claire,
It’s great to hear that you like this kind of bread. It’s not that common outside north of Europe. The dough can be a bit ragged, but maybe not dry. However, I think you should just give it a try and see how it turns out. Adding too much water is a bit hazardous. You may get a so-called flying crust. A big pocket on top between the crumb and the crust.
I don’t have any experience with malt extract as it’s not that common here in Sweden, but any sweetener with lots of taste will do. Perhaps molasses or even maple syrup.
Hi, the bread came out nicely, thank you for the recipe. However, I find that it is much much too salty. If someone isn’t used to large amounts of salt, I suggest to cut down the amount.
Hello! Your recipe is wonderful, the taste is perfect. Here, I’m in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, this bread is very expensive, I had tried other recipes but I didn’t get good results, thank you for sharing it.
The center of the bread has withered … what could be the cause?
Thanks
I’m glad you liked it, Maria.
I’m not sure I understand what you mean by withered? Has it become dry in the center only? Or is that it has collapsed a bit?
I’ve just found your website and am so excited. I’ve had a rye levain now for 9 months and have made wheat loaves and spelt. Still very new to this and making bread for the birds ? but am constantly searching for my go to loaf. Desperate to try a rye loaf so am going to start this today. I have a question about some of your other recipes. I don’t discard my starter as I keep it small and in the fridge and take what I need then feed it. I then feed the taken amount twice before use as I’ve read that the starter has to be fed fresh to make my bread. So when you say use discarded starter does that mean for crackers etc the starter doesn’t need fresh feeding? Happy baking ?
PS can I use raw honey instead of bread syrup ?
I have never tasted raw honey, so I don’t know that much about it. You can use whatever sweetener you want, but you will probably not get that typical “Swedish” taste, but who knows? Maybe it will taste better with honey. Give it a try and see what you think. You can also use molasses or dark cany syrup.
Hi Avril,
Welcome to Sourdough&olives. I hope you will have some nice experiences with my recipes. Using a discarded starter is actually a way to stop wasting the part you have to remove when feeding your starter. Some people have developed routines to avoid that, like you, and that is great. It may not sound very much to waste half a cup of starter now and then, but in a year it can become quite a lot. If you don’t discard any of your starters you can just add some unfed starter instead. Most of the time it’s just for flavoring and not for fermentation.
Thank you for replying so quickly. I’ve spent hours on your website today reading. So much out there about sourdough but not many with the knowledge and experience that you have. Also over the years of reading about sourdough I know what I’m looking for even if I don’t get the loaves right all the time. It is interesting how many different variations of starters and ingredients out there. I got the method for my starter 4 years ago from Shipton Mill website. My original one went mouldy when it was neglected due to my father being very ill, He came to live with us as he needed a lot of care. So second ‘Lubbley’ was born in March 2020. I use rye on its own for my starter so I can use it for wheat free loaves and hope to try making spelt and rye my main ingredients. At 6 months old I used a bit to start a gf starter ‘bubbley. It’s good to know that I can try using an unfed starter. Thank you ?
There are probably as many variations of starters and methods as there are sourdough bakers out there. You can always create your own method that serves you best. A rye starter has a tendency to develop mold more easily than a wheat starter if you don’t look after it. On the other hand, a rye starter is more active. I use a mix of rye and wheat in my starter. Spelt has a unique flavor, but it’s not as forgiving as “regular” wheat. But probably healthier.
It sounds like you are on the right track in your sourdough adventure. Look at recipes for guidance, but don’t be afraid to try to change things to your liking.
And don’t hesitate to contact me if you have any questions. I will do my best to help you if I can.
Thank you I will be careful to watch that it doesn’t mold. I keep it in the fridge and feed it roughly once a week. I made your rye loaf and oh my goodness it’s sooooo good. Thank you so much. I am really happy as I have a delicate stomach and lots of bread doesn’t go down well with me. So I try to make healthier loaves. Now I have ? Even my husband tried it and he’s never liked pumpernickel. Woke my son up at 10pm to try it when it was ready to slice. He thought it was delicious too and wanted more ?. I have sliced and frozen one of them wrapped very well to see how it goes. I’ve tagged you in my Instagram post, hope that was ok. Thank you ?
I’m so glad that you had such success with that recipe, Avril. It’s comments like this that give me the inspiration to continue with this blog. Many thanks.
So glad it helps. Please continue with your blog. I appreciate the work you put in ??
Hi Tomas,
I have a question about timing in the oven. It’s not clear for me how long should the dough sit in the oven at 215F? As I understood 20 min at 480F, 70 min at 390F.
As you answered in previous comment the overall time should be about 2-3 hours.
I bake my dough in Cloche Clay Bread Baker with lid. Should I take the bread out of the Baker and put to the over again for 10-15 min and when?
Thank you,
Victoria
Hi Victoria,
As you say, the total time in the oven should be about 20+70 minutes, 90 minutes in total. Check the inner temperature if you have a thermometer. It should be 215ºF / 100ºC.
The 2-3 hours was actually an answer to the length of the final rise and have nothing to do with the time in the oven.
When the bread is ready, take it out from the oven and let it cool. Meanwhile, you can lower the temperature to 215ºF / 100ºC.
When the bread is cool enough to handle, you can take it out from the clay baker and place it into the oven again. This step is not necessary, but it will give the bread a crust at the bottom that will prevent it from molding.
Good luck
Tomas
Thank you Tomas,
I baked this bread 2 times following your recipe but inner temperature of the bread never reached 215F, the highest inner temperature was 211F at the end of 70 min period when oven temperature was 390F. The bread was flat and gooey inside. The crust was crisp. I really love the test of this bread anyway and I am going to achieve a perfection in baking this particular bread. Could you please help me to understand what I did wrong?
My clay baker has sizes 14 X 5 X 4 1/4”. My dough raised to 25% before I put it to the oven. I use 100% rye starter.
Thank you for your help!
Victoria
Hi again,
The first thing you should try is to give it more time in the oven. Add 20-30 minutes. If you are using a cold clay baker, it may take a longer time to heat it compared to a bread tin.
Ps. I use one half amount of the ingredients mentioned in your recipe for my clay baker.
Thank you Tomas,
I will try. I used a preheated clay baker but it may cooled a little bit during putting dough in it.
Hello – just wanted to let you know that the second rise, once you have put the dough into the bread pans, is omitted from the Print version. I’ll let you know how it turns out without that rise :-).
Thanks for informing me, Kristi, and I’m so sorry.
It must have disappeared when I changed the recipe plugin. I have corrected it now.
Hi Thomas!
Baked yesterday and it turned out great, although crumb a little more dense than yours. Good taste, very filling. Could not wait 24 hours – really?!? 🙂
I used Bob’s Red Mill Dark Rye Flour and regular cane syrup, which is mostly corn syrup, but it was all that I had at short notice.
Will definitely bake it again. Thank you!
I know. Waiting 24 hours is hard. But I think your crumb will benefit from it. I’m so glad you liked the recipe, by the way.
Hello Tomas
I am not sure if you are monitoring this website any longer – but I will take that chance! My first try at this bread is currently in for its second proof. I may have made a major mistake, but time will tell. Here is what I did. I wanted a really earthy bread, so rather than the 150 grams sunflower, I used rye chops (broken rye berries). I soaked these with the other seeds over night, and it seemed as though there was no water to drain off as it had all been absorbed. However, my dough looks MUCH wetter than yours, so I am thinking that I have made a mistake. Alas, I will have learned if nothing else. My problem is that I am inclined to tweak recipes, even on the first go, which has led to interesting results. I do love rye chops – so could you recommend a ratio of rye chops to sunflower seeds? Thank you very much!
Hello Tess,
I’m still active at Sourdough&olives, just not as much just now. I’m actually thinking about how to proceed with this blog.
I think the problem here is the rye berries. Rye flour absorbs lots of water (more than wheat flour), so rye berries probably do the same. At least much more than sunflower seeds. This means that the dough will have higher hydration.
This is not necessarily anything wrong if the end result is good. I don’t know the ratio of rye chops to sunflower seeds, but next time you can measure the water added to the rye chops. If all or most of it is absorbed, you can reduce the same amount of water added in the recipe.
thank you for this suggestion. My first attempt was a bust – but the birds and squirrels were happy! I will go back to the start and make this recipe 100% to your directions so I know how it should be – then I will try some tweaking! I am thinking maybe substitute rye chops for only about 25% of the sunflower kernels might be a good starting place. Thank you for responding, and I appreciate all the time you have taken to share your recipes. Have a wonderful holiday season!