NOTE! This recipe requires cream with a fat content of at least 37%
Butter is the chef’s best friend. At least in the western world. Try to imagine French cuisine without butter. Impossible. And I’m sure that even the Italian chefs use butter now and then even though they claim that they prefer olive oil.
Olive oil is also one of the most useful things you can have in a kitchen, but it can not always replace real butter. Think mushrooms fried with butter and parsley, Beurre Blanc, or fried herring with mashed potatoes and lingonberries.
The last dish is a classic Swedish course, so many of you may not know about it. But I can assure you that it is as impossible for a Swede to cook it in anything but butter as it would be for a Frenchman to use margarine in Bernaise sauce.
But the butter has also been questioned for a long time because it is considered to cause health problems. It contains saturated fat, and everybody knows that saturated fat is BAD. It’s not as dreadful as trans fat, but almost.
But lately, voices have been heard that claim the opposite. Maybe butter isn’t that bad after all. Maybe it can even be good for you.
What is right and what is wrong?
The truth is probably somewhere in between. I think butter is a natural food that contains a lot of nutrients that are good for the body. But I do not believe that one should exaggerate the consumption of it.
But it’s impossible to resist butter completely. Few ingredients can alone transform a dish from being mediocre to excellent. Butter is capable of doing that because it tastes so divinely.
So now that you know that you have to use butter, at least sometimes, here are some useful tips.
You don’t have to store your butter in the refrigerator.
Butter is about 80% fat and has a low water content. That makes it less susceptible to bacterial growth. But it’s advisable to store only salted butter at room temperature as the salt adds protection.
Store it in small batches, covered to protect it from light and air, not more than you use during a week. Because finally, it will go rancid.
It’s not dangerous, but it tastes bad, and the only thing to do is to waste it. Wasting food is something that we must always try to avoid. Especially something so magical as butter.
But what’s the benefit of storing butter at room temperature?
It will be easier to spread it on your breakfast toast.
Butter that is taken directly from the refrigerator is almost impossible to spread on soft bread. And sometimes some recipes require softened butter.
You can soften butter by grating it.
Maybe you are still suspicious about leaving the butter out on the counter. No problem. You can still bring it to room temperature quickly by grating it with the cheese grater. The thin slices will soften in no time.
It’s possible to fry in very high temperatures with butter.
But first, you have to clarify it. In addition to fat, butter also contains protein, sugar, and water, and it’s the protein and sugar that causes it to burn.
Let the butter melt over low heat in a saucepan until you start to see white foam on the surface. Skim the foam off the surface. Now you have a layer of pure fat over a layer of white liquid in the bottom.
Gently pour the fat into a suitable container, leaving behind the white liquid from the bottom of the pan.
Now you have clarified butter that can handle high temperatures and can replace most oils for frying. It is also an excellent replacement for Ghee which is included in many Indian dishes.
It is also almost lactose-free as most of the sugar was left behind in that white liquid, remember?
Use everything when you make brown butter.
You have probably heard that you shall strain the brown butter from the particles in the bottom of the saucepan. Don’t do that next time. These particles contribute with a minor taste explosion.
Reuse the wrappers.
Not to wrap new butter of course. But they are perfect for greasing sheets, pans, and casseroles.
When is it advisable to exchange butter for margarine?
Never. Margarine is the foods counterpart to Darth Vader.
I have also included an easy recipe for homemade butter. Some of you have maybe already made your own butter, but have you tried to do it with sour cream? Sour cream will give the butter just a hint of sourness. Spread it on a slice of bread and you don’t need any more toppings. Perhaps the way butter tasted when the Vikings introduced it to the rest of the northern Europe. At least my ancestors could do something right, and not only create a huge mess wherever the went. But the Frenchmen got their revenge for all plundering and misery. Today they sell their butter expensive in Swedish delicatessen stores.
Sour cream butter
Ingredients
- 2 cup sour cream, 30% fat content Creme Fraiche works fine as well
- salt to taste optional
Instructions
- Pour the cream in a big kitchen bowl, and whisk it with a hand mixer on medium speed. Continue to whisk until the butter starts to separate. It will take some time, so don't lose your patience.
- Pour off the buttermilk. Rinse the butter by pouring ice water over it and pressing the remaining buttermilk out with a small spatula or a spoon. You can also knead it by hand if you can stand the cold water. When the water starts to go "milky" it's time to pour it off and add some new. Continue like this until the water is completely clear and all buttermilk is pressed out from the butter.
- Add salt and work it trough the butter.
49 Comments
Get piece. We never keep butter in the fridge. Our kitchen is coll during the winter but warn in the real summer months (then the butter barely stays solid).
Since I bake breads some of which require butter, Mike etc. I like the butter room temperature.
Finally, since my kitchen is cool during the winter I use a proofing over, especially for my sourdough breads.
It’s the same here in Sweden. Cold in the winter but warm in the summer. When it’s too cold in the kitchen I use to proof in the oven with the lamp lit only.
I want to try this! Can anyone tell me how much butter to expect from 2 cups of sour cream? If you add salt, what is a reasonable amount? Thanks in advance to anyone who can answer .
I think you can expect about 150 grams/ 5.2 oz of butter. I think 3/4 a teaspoon of salt is quite reasonable.
I have tried this with pasteurized sour cream and it never separated after quite a while in the food processor. I gave up. Is there something I can add?
Hi Jeff,
How ,long did you run it? It took a LOOONG time for me as well, but suddenly everything happened in just a minute.
How long should I whip it in my mixer?
Until the butter starts to separate. It should look like it does on picture 5 from the top of the post.
Good morning Tomas,
When you say “it took a loooong time”, how much time do you guess it took? It would help us to know in case we should give up. Did it take as long as an hour?
Many thanks,
Hi Alicia,
Oh no, it doesn’t take that long. I would have given up myself long before that.
It takes about 10 – 15 minutes.
Is it buttermilk that is left over?
Yes, it is. It’s a traditional buttermilk. The buttermilk you buy today is often ordinary low-fat milk with added bacteria culture.
Mine is taking more than 45 mnts. Not sure if I am doing something wrong
I’m confused y’all, i processed my sour cream for over an hour till it was warm. You said for a looonnnggg time but how how long and do I need to add some heavy cream or cream of tartar to it?
This may help:Excerpt from “How To Make Butter in a Blender”
by EMMA CHRISTENSEN
“How quickly this happens can depend on your blender and the temperature of the cream, but it generally takes between two and 10 minutes; the high-powered blenders will take around two minutes.”
Well, I only have a cheap hand mixer, so no wonder it took some time. Interesting about the temperature. I didn’t know that. Thanks for the info, Brandon.
Complete fail. I’ve made cultured butter before and was hoping this would be a great shortcut. Whipped and whipped and all I got was a very messy kitchen. I wonder if industrial dairy products are different here.
That’s weird. I have made this butter many times and never failed. Do you remember how much fat content there was in the sour cream?
This recipe doesn’t work. Learn from the six hours of work I put into it yesterday. Don’t waste your time. I got 75 pounds of sour cream as a gift yesterday. We don’t eat much sour cream but we eat butter, so I googled this recipe. I mixed fast, slow, with a hand mixer, with a kitchenaid, I let it get warm, I cooled it off, I added citric acid, when it didn’t turn quickly, I Ley it mix for up to an hour. Absolutely nothing made any difference.
Possibly in Sweden, there’s a product called “sour cream” that acts differently, but what I got here in the US absolutely didn’t work.
Hi Thomas.
I’m sorry to hear that you had problems with the recipe.
I still think it works just fine to make butter with sour cream. As I understand it, sour cream is fermented ordinary cream, just like creme fraiche.
However, there are a few things you should be aware of.
Low-fat products don’t work very well for obvious reasons.
But even UHT (ultra high temperature) processed cream is not suitable for making butter. I will update the recipe regarding this.
75 pounds of sour cream? That’s a heck of a gift!
The label probably doesn’t explicitly state the percent milk fat. I looked at a 3 lb tub of Daisy sour cream at Costco today, and on the nutritional info section, it says that a “serving is 30 g and that a serving contains 5 g total fat. Dividing 5 into 30 gives you the percent fat: 16.67%
That is about the same fat level as commercial “half & half.” The USDA defines “half & half” as between 10.5% and 18% fat. Sour cream, under CFR 21, section 131.160, can in no case contain less than 14.4% fat. Cream, on the other hand, falls into 3 categories. “Light cream” must contain 18-30% fat. “Light whipping cream” has to be between 30-36% fat. “Heavy cream” must be above 36% fat.
So, “sour cream” sold in the US is perhaps a bit of a misnomer. Maybe it should really be called “sour half & half,” but the USDA says otherwise!
I believe you must use unpasteurized product. If you use pasteurized, the needed cultures have been removed then added back. It’s not the same as natural. I’ve also found that not only does the sour cream need to be cold, the bowl should be too. Using a metal bowl works a lot better than glass. Just my two cents y’all. Butter is one of the foods of the gods. ?
Hi Nanny.
I don’t think so. I have used normally pasteurized products for sure. They are not allowed to sell unpasteurized dairy products here in Sweden. I do think you are partly right, though. I think heavily treated products, like UHT and such, can be a problem.
I do think you can be right about cold cream and metal bowl. I always use that.
You are absolutely right that butter is food for the gods. It’s so freaking delicious it’s almost ridiculous.
Thanks for your recipe, I just waned to see if people use sour cream for making ghee:)
A comment: Clarified butter that you get after heating butter is actually Ghee, not replacement of Ghee as mentioned in the recipe. I am from India and my family has been making butter and ghee for as long as I remember.
Hi there.
Many thanks for your input. So clarified butter and Ghee is the same thing? I didn’t realize that. I have read so many recipes where you have to heat the butter to get a Maillard reaction etc, to get real ghee.
For all the people that failed this-check the following – are you using milk cream or some sort of substitude, like vegetable cream, that whips well, but does not make butter.
For UHT treated products, that come from milk – you just need to culture it yourself. Use 2tbsp kefir or yoghurt per litre, and leave in the kitchen (not the fridge) at room temp for 24h, covered. Then beat the resulting yoghurt like substance till separation.
Great advice. Many thanks.
One of the issues that might stop the sour cream from separating is there are added preservatives and stabilizers. You really need to get a sour cream with just cultured cream and maybe salt. If it has any gums or sodium citrate you could leave your stand mixer going all night and it will never separate the buttermilk and butter fat.
Mom and dad had their own cows and separated the milk from the cream. The cream was allowed to sour and as it did it thickened. They had a butter churn with wooden paddles and it was the job of us kids to turn the handle until we had butter. The buttermilk was poured off and the butter cleaned with clear, cold water. It was the best tasting butter on freshly baked warm bread! I have been trying to find sour cream butter for years!
Hi Judith,
I can imagine it must have tasted amazing. Not many people get to experience such a thing today.
I tried to make butter from sour cream from Walmart but after 10 minutes I gave up. I’m wondering if the term sour cream means creams that has turned sour by leaving it on the counter for a day or two. My mom made butter this way and it made the best butter but I don’t think making it from actual grocery store sour cream will work.
I made this from grocery store Daisy-brand sour cream today and it turned out great. I mixed it in my Kitchenaid with the wire whisk thing on high for somewhere between 10 and 15 minutes. Put a towel over the mixer! In the beginning it won’t splash, but at the end it definitely will. It pretty quickly went from sour cream to a kind of whipped cream, then collapsed into a liquid, and then finally separated into butterfat and buttermilk. I pressed out and poured off the buttermilk, then added a cup of icewater, ran the mixer again for 2 min, and poured off the cloudy water, repeating until the water was pretty clear. Then pressed out any final water, added about 1/2 tsp of salt, ran the mixer again to combine, and pressed it into a mason jar. Came out perfectly – like a tangy sweet cream butter.
Hi Michael,
Great to hear about your successful results. The way you described the process, sounds very similar to the way I make butter.
Tomas – Are you using “Gräddfil” in Sweden? Because I’m only seeing that at 12% fat content. Daisy (pretty standard here in the US) is about 17%. We have heavy cream that is as much as 40% milkfat, though.
I’m just wondering where you got the 30% milkfat number – I’ve never seen sour cream with that high % milkfat.
No, the fat content in gräddfil on its own is probably a bit low, about 12%, as you mentioned. I have never tried it, though, so I’m not sure. But if you mix it with creme fraiche you can get something that works. I have used creme fraiche only sometimes, and that gives an even better result.
Unfortunately, Melissa Huber could not leave a comment because she was blocked for unknown reasons.
This is her comment:
“Hi there!
I tried to leave a comment on the sour cream butter recipe but I was getting a notice it was blocked because it thought I was a bot?? Lol
Anyway heres my comment in case you can add it!People are literally in the dark about the products were being sold!The 75 pound sour cream guy had really shitty sour cream! Lol But he has no idea! Even most of our flour is crap! I buy most of my flour from Italy! Americans are fat for a reason! Our government is allowing it! Its all about bigger profits!!
My comment:I used homemade sour cream which I made using non homogenized lightly pasteurized heavy cream. A note for USA cooks!Some of our sour creams in the stores are CRAP and have additives,stabilizers,emulsifiers and thickeners in them so you will have to experiment to see which brand if any will work!Any emulsifier will keep it from separating properly. Once you really start researching dairy products in the USA you may be surprised! Anyone who’s attempted to make cheese knows what I’m talking about! Its very difficult to find really good high quality milk! Once I finally did- I now make my own yogurt, butter, sour cream and cheese!Homemade cream top yogurt is heaven!I feel bad that guy blamed you for his 75 pound sour cream problem but the FACT is it was CRAP sour cream and thats not your fault! This recipe WORKS! If it doesn’t its because of YOUR sour cream!”
The author specified sour cream made by fermenting. My (American) sour cream is cultured. So it’s basically plain yogurt instead of real sour cream. BTW, as I write this I’m looking at a melted smoking mess that used to be my mixer. I guess 1hour20minutes is a bit above it’s rated duty cycle
My sour.cream lists: cultured cream, milk,salt. As the ingredients. No reference to any percentage.
It says 30% fat content in the recipe list.
Up date!!! Went and bought Daisy brand (3lbs) as per a previous commentors. After another 90 minute mix, I’ve got nothing but runny sour cream.
Since I don’t live in the US I don’t have any experience with Daisy brand. I searched for it on Google and found 2 products, one with 16% fat content and one with 8%. That is not enough to make butter. You need 30% fat content. But perhaps they have other products with higher fat content? Please let me know the fat content of the product you are using.
The label probably doesn’t explicitly state the percent milk fat. I looked at a 3 lb tub of Daisy sour cream at Costco today, and on the nutritional info section, it says that a “serving is 30 g and that a serving contains 5 g total fat. Dividing 5 into 30 gives you the percent fat: 16.67%
That is about the same fat level as commercial “half & half.” The USDA defines “half & half” as between 10.5% and 18% fat. Sour cream, under CFR 21, section 131.160, can in no case contain less than 14.4% fat. Cream, on the other hand, falls into 3 categories. “Light cream” must contain 18-30% fat. “Light whipping cream” has to be between 30-36% fat. “Heavy cream” must be above 36% fat.
So, “sour cream” sold in the US is perhaps a bit of a misnomer. Maybe it should really be called “sour half & half,” but the USDA says otherwise!
I was a city boy from Portland Oregon and moved to rural Nevada in 1968 when I was 13. I was used to sweet cream butter that you know of.
Then I was introduced to sour cream butter.
As you can imagine I did not like sour cream butter at first. Sour cream butter is intentionally waiting for cream to go sour before making the butter. It gives a wang to the butter. You can tell by looking at the butter it is different because it has a marbled pattern look to it, not the solid yellow.
Like horseradish sauce and jalapeno sour cream, tastes that grow on you, I switched from liking sweet cream butter to sour cream butter. We used to say we preferred sour cream butter versus “school lunch butter” which we got at school.
But those were the days. I don’t think I have tasted it in 45 years.Probably wouldn’t like it now but would like to try. An acquired taste.
I wasted a container of Daisy sour cream. It would not separate. It says it’s 85 percent fat. Please tell me how this brand worked for some people. I love the taste of sour cream country butter from my youth but can’t find it anymore.
Ps. I ended up with sour whipped cream. I sweetened it and found it quite delicious on berries.
A beater or food processor blade is unlikely to work. You need a wire whisk. Think whipped cream taken too far.
How long does it take for the butter to separate??? ave it going for over an hour and nothing.
Great recipe. Thankyou.